Benchmarks

90 ‘Omnichannel’ Sites Ranked by User Experience Performance

Use the interactive UX benchmark chart below to see the ranked UX performance of 90 leading Omnichannel e-commerce sites in the US and Europe. ‘Omnichannel’ is here defined as e-commerce sites that also have physical stores, and utilize this on their website, e.g. with ‘Buy Online, Pickup In-Store’ (BOPIS), store availability features, or similar. Each of the 90 Omnichannel sites has been manually rated across 1162 different e-commerce UX elements, all based on Baymard’s 150,000+ hours of UX research.

This is a sub-set of the full benchmark which includes 123 e-commerce sites.

Case Studies

Click the colored dots to view in-depth case studies for each benchmarked site, or scroll down to see all case studies. You can also view the case study examples organized by type of page.

Benchmark UX Performances
Poor
Mediocre
Decent
Good
Perfect

Overall UX Performance

1162 Guidelines

Desktop Web

413 Guidelines

Homepage & Category

31 Guidelines

Homepage

8 Guidelines

Category Taxonomy

10 Guidelines

Main Navigation

7 Guidelines

Intermediary Category Pages

6 Guidelines

On-Site Search

28 Guidelines

Search Query Types

10 Guidelines

Search Autocomplete

8 Guidelines

Search Form & Search Results

10 Guidelines

Product Lists & Filtering

68 Guidelines

List Layout

14 Guidelines

List Item Info

10 Guidelines

List Item Thumbnails

7 Guidelines

List Item Features

11 Guidelines

Filtering: Available Filters

8 Guidelines

Filtering: Scope & Logic

9 Guidelines

Filtering: Interface & Layout

4 Guidelines

Sorting

5 Guidelines

Product Page

97 Guidelines

Product Page Layout

8 Guidelines

Cross-Sells & Cross-Navigation

8 Guidelines

Image Gallery UI

9 Guidelines

Product Images, Videos & 360-Views

14 Guidelines

Product Descriptions

7 Guidelines

Product Variations

9 Guidelines

Specifications Sheet

5 Guidelines

The 'Buy' Section

9 Guidelines

Shipping, Returns, and Gifting

8 Guidelines

User Reviews

20 Guidelines

Cart & Checkout

117 Guidelines

Shopping Cart

16 Guidelines

Account Selection & Creation

7 Guidelines

User Information & Address

17 Guidelines

Gifting Flow & Features

5 Guidelines

Shipping & Fulfillment

11 Guidelines

Payment Flow & Credit Card Form

16 Guidelines

Order Review & Confirmation

10 Guidelines

General Form Design and Checkout Layout

19 Guidelines

Form Field Usability and Design

16 Guidelines

Customer Accounts

31 Guidelines

Account Drop-Down & Sign In

7 Guidelines

Account Dashboard

5 Guidelines

'Your Account': Addresses, Payments, & Newsletters

12 Guidelines

Account-Wide Navigation, Structure, & Information

7 Guidelines

Site-Wide Features

14 Guidelines

Order Tracking & Returns

27 Guidelines

Orders & Order Tracking

15 Guidelines

Order Returns

12 Guidelines

Mobile Web

405 Guidelines

Mobile Web Homepage & Category Navigation

30 Guidelines

Mobile Web Homepage

9 Guidelines

Mobile Web Category Taxonomy

10 Guidelines

Mobile Web Main Navigation

6 Guidelines

Mobile Web Intermediary Category Pages

5 Guidelines

Mobile Web On-Site Search

30 Guidelines

Mobile Web Search Query Types

10 Guidelines

Mobile Web Search Autocomplete

7 Guidelines

Mobile Web Search Form & Results

13 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Lists & Filtering

63 Guidelines

Mobile Web List Layout

15 Guidelines

Mobile Web List Item Info

12 Guidelines

Mobile Web List Item Thumbnails

8 Guidelines

Mobile Web List Item Features

8 Guidelines

Mobile Web Filtering & Sorting: Filter & Sort Types

9 Guidelines

Mobile Web Filtering & Sorting: Scope & Logic

6 Guidelines

Mobile Web Filtering: Interface & Layout

5 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Page

91 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Page Layout, Cross-Sells, & Cross-Navigation

13 Guidelines

Mobile Web Image Gallery UI

6 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Images, Videos & 360-Views

13 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Descriptions

8 Guidelines

Mobile Web Product Variations

9 Guidelines

Mobile Web Specifications Sheet

5 Guidelines

Mobile Web "Buy" Section

9 Guidelines

Mobile Web Shipping, Returns, and Gifting

8 Guidelines

Mobile Web User Reviews

20 Guidelines

Mobile Web Cart & Checkout

117 Guidelines

Mobile Web Shopping Cart

15 Guidelines

Mobile Web Account Selection & Creation

7 Guidelines

Mobile Web User Information & Address

17 Guidelines

Mobile Web Gifting Flow & Features

5 Guidelines

Mobile Web Shipping & Fulfillment

11 Guidelines

Mobile Web Payment Flow & Credit Card Form

16 Guidelines

Mobile Web Order Review & Confirmation

9 Guidelines

Mobile Web "General Form Design and Checkout Layout "

17 Guidelines

Mobile Web Form Field Usability and Design

20 Guidelines

Mobile Web Customer Accounts

25 Guidelines

Mobile Web Account Sign In & Dashboard

7 Guidelines

'Mobile Web Account': Addresses, Payments, & Newsletters

12 Guidelines

Mobile Web Account-Wide Navigation, Structure, & Information

6 Guidelines

Mobile Web Site-Wide Features

22 Guidelines

Mobile Web Order Tracking & Returns

27 Guidelines

Mobile Web Orders & Order Tracking

15 Guidelines

Mobile Web Order Returns

12 Guidelines

Mobile App

344 Guidelines

Mobile App Homepage & Category Navigation

27 Guidelines

Mobile App Homepage

7 Guidelines

Mobile App Category Taxonomy

9 Guidelines

Mobile App Main Navigation

6 Guidelines

Mobile App Intermediary Category Pages

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Search

26 Guidelines

Mobile App Search Query Types

8 Guidelines

Mobile App Search Autocomplete

7 Guidelines

Mobile App Search Form & Results

11 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Lists & Filtering

54 Guidelines

Mobile App List Layout

14 Guidelines

Mobile App List Item Info

11 Guidelines

Mobile App List Item Thumbnails

5 Guidelines

Mobile App List Item Features

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Filtering & Sorting: Filter & Sort Types

9 Guidelines

Mobile App Filtering & Sorting: Scope & Logic

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Filtering: Interface & Layout

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Page

86 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Page Layout & Cross-Sells

13 Guidelines

Mobile App Image Gallery UI

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Images, Videos, & 360-Views

13 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Descriptions

8 Guidelines

Mobile App Product Variations

7 Guidelines

Mobile App Specifications Sheet

5 Guidelines

Mobile App "Buy" Section

9 Guidelines

Mobile App Shipping, Returns, and Gifting

8 Guidelines

Mobile App User Reviews

18 Guidelines

Mobile App Cart & Checkout

114 Guidelines

Mobile App Shopping Cart

15 Guidelines

Mobile App Account Selection & Creation

7 Guidelines

Mobile App User Information & Address

16 Guidelines

Mobile App Gifting Flow & Features

5 Guidelines

Mobile App Shipping & Fulfillment

11 Guidelines

Mobile App Payment Flow & Credit Card Form

15 Guidelines

Mobile App Order Review & Confirmation

9 Guidelines

Mobile App "General Form Design and Checkout Layout "

17 Guidelines

Mobile App Form Field Usability and Design

19 Guidelines

Mobile App Customer Accounts

22 Guidelines

Mobile App Account Dashboard

5 Guidelines

'Mobile App Account': Addresses, Payments, & Newsletters

12 Guidelines

Mobile App Account-Wide Navigation, Structure, & Information

5 Guidelines

App-Wide Features

15 Guidelines

Case Studies

Deep dive into any of the 90 retail sites displayed in the scatter plot above.

decent
Crutchfield
Electronics & Office

50 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
REI
Sports Gear & Equipment

53 page designs: mobile, desktop

decent
L.L.Bean
Apparel & Accessories

60 page designs: mobile, desktop

decent
Lowe’s
Home & Hardware

83 page designs: mobile, app, desktop

decent
Target
Mass Merchant

87 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

decent
Ace Hardware
Home & Hardware

51 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
John Lewis
Mass Merchant

60 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
Gamma
Home & Hardware

38 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
Jimmy Choo
Apparel & Accessories

51 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
Best Buy
Electronics & Office

80 page designs: mobile, desktop, app

decent
Kohl’s
Mass Merchant

56 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
Home Depot
Home & Hardware

94 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

decent
Van Cleef & Arpels
Apparel & Accessories

42 page designs: desktop, mobile

decent
Sephora
Health & Beauty

90 page designs: app, mobile, desktop

decent
Macy’s
Apparel & Accessories

87 page designs: mobile, desktop, app

decent
Walmart
Mass Merchant

87 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

mediocre
Crate & Barrel
Furniture & Home Decor

81 page designs: app, desktop, mobile

mediocre
La Redoute
Apparel & Accessories

59 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
E. Breuninger
Apparel & Accessories

53 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Adidas
Apparel & Accessories

59 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
Gamestop
Toys & Crafts

41 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Nordstrom
Apparel & Accessories

80 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

mediocre
IKEA
Furniture & Home Decor

97 page designs: mobile, desktop, app

mediocre
Evo
Sports Gear & Equipment

43 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
OBI
Home & Hardware

50 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Louis Vuitton
Apparel & Accessories

48 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Academy
Sports Gear & Equipment

43 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Marks & Spencer
Apparel & Accessories

88 page designs: mobile, desktop, app

mediocre
Gucci
Apparel & Accessories

57 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
The Vitamin Shoppe
Vitamins & Supplements

45 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Staples
Electronics & Office

79 page designs: app, mobile, desktop

mediocre
Sports Direct
Sports Gear & Equipment

43 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
JCPenney
Apparel & Accessories

59 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
MediaMarkt
Electronics & Office

47 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Foot Locker
Apparel & Accessories

51 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
CHANEL
Health & Beauty

46 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
CVS
Health & Beauty

41 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
SportChek
Sports Gear & Equipment

40 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
TAG Heuer
Apparel & Accessories

44 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Williams Sonoma
Furniture & Home Decor

58 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Neiman Marcus
Apparel & Accessories

51 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Walgreens
Health & Beauty

48 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Smyths
Toys & Crafts

42 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Bang & Olufsen
Electronics & Office

25 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Disney Store
Toys & Crafts

42 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
Dick’s Sporting Goods
Sports Gear & Equipment

46 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
RTV Euro AGD
Electronics & Office

47 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
reserved
Apparel & Accessories

52 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Apple
Electronics & Office

55 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Urban Outfitters
Apparel & Accessories

51 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Office Depot
Electronics & Office

52 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
Backcountry
Sports Gear & Equipment

39 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Bell
Telco

41 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Guitar Center
Pets & Hobbies

40 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Advance Auto Parts
Automotive Parts & Specialty

27 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Costco
Mass Merchant

65 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Northern Tool
Home & Hardware

63 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Cabela’s
Sports Gear & Equipment

46 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
LEGO
Toys & Crafts

44 page designs: mobile, desktop

mediocre
Ann Taylor
Apparel & Accessories

45 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Menards
Home & Hardware

44 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Bass Pro Shops
Sports Gear & Equipment

38 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
B&Q
Home & Hardware

45 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Nike
Apparel & Accessories

98 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

mediocre
H&M
Apparel & Accessories

88 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

mediocre
Fnac
Electronics & Office

49 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
GAP
Apparel & Accessories

76 page designs: mobile, desktop, app

mediocre
Spectrum
Internet Service Providers

17 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Verizon
Telco

43 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Sears
Mass Merchant

59 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Vodafone UK
Telco

39 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Tire Rack
Automotive Parts & Specialty

30 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Hibbett
Sports Gear & Equipment

49 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
Victoria’s Secret
Apparel & Accessories

56 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
COX
Internet Service Providers

30 page designs: desktop, mobile

mediocre
The Entertainer (TheToyShop.com)
Toys & Crafts

43 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
American Eagle
Apparel & Accessories

45 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Vitamin World
Vitamins & Supplements

38 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Demon Tweeks
Automotive Parts & Specialty

25 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Grainger
Home & Hardware

56 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Leroy Merlin
Home & Hardware

45 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
ECS Tuning
Automotive Parts & Specialty

31 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Orange
Telco

39 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Debenhams
Apparel & Accessories

59 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Albertsons
Online Grocery

72 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

poor
Pep Boys
Automotive Parts & Specialty

26 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Tesco
Mass Merchant

47 page designs: desktop, mobile

poor
Stop & Shop
Online Grocery

82 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

poor
Sainsbury’s
Online Grocery

84 page designs: desktop, mobile, app

poor
Xfinity
Telco

16 page designs: desktop, mobile


User Experience Research, Delivered Twice a Month

Join 25,000+ UX professionals and get a new UX article every second week.

A screenshot of the UX article newsletter
Premium Research

Get full access to Baymard’s 78,000+ hours of research and empower your UX team and decisions.

Audit Service

Get Baymard to audit your site’s UX performance, compare it to competitors, and identify 40 areas of improvements.